Bill Seeking Establishment of Electoral Offences Commission Passes 2nd Reading in Senate

Political violence precipitates vicious cycles of political instability and national insecurity -Senator Kyari

BY OBUTE JAMES

A bill seeking the establishment of an electoral offences commission on Wednesday passed Second Reading in the Senate

The bill sponsored by Senator Abubakar Kyari, representative of Borno North Senatorial District is titled “a Bill to establish the National Electoral Offences Commission and for Related Matters, 2020 (SB. 220),

In his lead debate, Senator Kyari who is the Chairman, Senate Committee on FCT, Abuja said that the commission is very imperative to divest the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) of the “burden” of prosecuting electoral offenders in Nigeria so that the commission will focus on its core constitutional mandate of conducting elections.

According to him, Political violence precipitates vicious cycles of political instability and national insecurity

Abubakar who enumerated the various problems and debilitating outcomes of electoral malpractices to include “low quality leadership,” citizens “political apathy,” “instability and national insecurity,” disintegration of “national cohesion” among many other ills called on his colleagues to support the bills and write the name of the 9th National Assembly with gold on Nigeria’s history.

“Electoral crimes lead to low quality, corrupt and violent political leadership. Electoral crimes help election riggers and offenders take control of government against the democratic will of the electorate.

“Electoral offences give birth to political apathy, that forces the electorate to incrementally disengage in political process.

“Electoral offences…precipitates vicious cycle of political instability and national insecurity, electoral corruption leads to avoidable waste of public resources and threatens National Development.

“Civil disturbances and violence resulting from manipulated elections [put an] end to otherwise harmonious communal relations among communities with adverse effect on national cohesion, peace and security.

Speaking further, Abubakar revealed that several other countries across the world had enacted similar laws which have in many ways helped to mainstream and strengthen good and credible electoral processes in those countries. Some of the countries referenced include, Malaysia (1954), United Kingdom (1983, 1985, 2000, 2006), Nepal (1990, amended 2007), Canada (2014), and Kenya 2016. He said that going by the example of Malaysia, Nigeria was already “63 years late” but must necessarily tow the same line in the interest of the growth and progress of the country.

Supporting the bill, Senator Surajudeen Ajibola (APC, Osun) said that the bill was timely and “will ensure crime free electoral process” in Nigeria.

Senator Sam Egwu (PDP, Ebonyi North) urged his colleagues to support the bill to save the lives of innocent Nigerians who constantly fall victim to electoral violence during election in Nigeria. Egwu declared that elections in Nigeria was usually “war because it is only [during] that people are killed.” He cited the killing of the PDP woman leader and a journalist in the last governorship elections in Kogi state and Bayelsa states respectively as a classic example of what electoral violence can cause.

While making his contribution on the bill debate, Senator Adamu Aliero (APC, Nassarawa) likened people that perpetrate electoral violence as being “worse than coup plotters.”

On the part of the Senate Leader, Yahaya Abdulahi (APC, Kebbi) electoral offenders are “existential threat to our democracy” and must be punished to save the nation. He called on his colleagues to support the bill.

Meanwhile, the Senate Minority Leader, Enyinnaya Abaribe (PDP, Abia South) while supporting the bill called on the sponsor of the bill to clearly differentiate the specific goal of the bill, to determine if either a “commission or tribunal” was being sought, this according to him was necessary based on the recommendations of the Justice Uwais led electoral reform committee recommendations which was cited as one of the sources of the bill.

Commenting along the line of thought of the Minority Leader, former Deputy Senate President, Ike Ekweremadu (PDP, Enugu West) cautioned the senate on the establishment of a commission noting that “the tendency for the government in power to weaponize” such a commission cannot be waved off easily in a country like Nigeria where politicians in power do everything to sustain their hold on power.

Ekweremadu, therefore recommended that in line with the Justice Uwais committee report, the bill should rather seek to establish an “electoral offences tribunal” that can be empowered to give commensurate punishment for offenders.

In his contribution to the debate, Senator Rochas Okorocha (APC – Imo West) advocated stiffer penalties and sanctions to serve as checks against electoral offenses such as rigging by officials of the electoral body.

Senator George Thompson Sekibo (PDP – Rivers East) said the establishment of an Electoral Offences Commission was long overdue.

According to the lawmaker, the 2023 General Elections will be marred with electoral violence like never witnessed before, should the National Assembly fail to pass the bill into law.

He, therefore, threw his weight behind the establishment of a tribunal alongside the proposed Commission.

“This request is long overdue. If we achieve this, we will be able to deepen our democracy. If we don’t achieve this, then 2023 will be worse.

“Electoral Act has many of this provisions, but the problem is who will implement it?

“We need the Commission, we also need the tribunal. Let it be surplus than having none.

“When it is passed, it should be assented to. If they don’t assent to it, then 2023 will be more than war,” Sekibo warned.

Senator Matthew Urhoghide (PDP – Edo South) said, “There is no amount of amendment to our electoral act devoid of the establishment of an institution for the purpose of punishing electoral offenses that will achieve any result.

“Anybody who commits, including political parties who commits electoral corruption, must be dealt with ruthlessly.”

Senator Francis Fadahunsi (PDP – Osun East), in his contribution said the responsibility of realizing a credible electoral system is one that begins with politicians.

He said unless politicians agree to have a sanitized electoral process in Nigeria, no amount of commission established will change the frequency of electoral offenses in the country.

Senator Adamu Bulkachuwa (APC – Bauchi North), while speaking in support of the establishment of the commission, said there is need to establish a special court so as to reduce congestion that may arise as a result of the number of petitions and electoral offenses that would go before the commission.

Senator Uche Ekwunife (PDP – Anambra Central) said, “For this act to work, it behoves on us the politicians.

“We are still the people that will make the environment conducive. If we follow the way we are doing elections in this country, there will be no democracy.”

According to the Senate President,Ahmad Lawan, the move to establish the Commission was in line with the legislative agenda of the Ninth National Assembly at sanitising Nigeria’s electoral process.

He said, “It is in pursuit of our legislative agenda at ensuring that we sanitise the electoral environment in the right direction.

“So, this bill is one of many that requires we amend the Electoral Act. Even Constitutional amendments and alterations will be made to that effect to ensure that the electoral processes and procedures are very well protected, that we stop people from abusing the process because they are in power, or because they have money.”

“I agree that the penalties must be punitive enough to make people not to indulge in electoral offenses,” Lawan added.

The Electoral Offences Commission Bill, which scaled second reading debate on the floor, was referred by the Senate President, Ahmad Lawan, to the Committee on Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) for further legislative work.

The Committee which is Chaired by Senator Kabiru Gaya (APC – Kano South) is expected to submit its report on the bill in four weeks.

Senator Abubakar Kyari, Chairman, Senate Committee on FCT, Abuja