BY OBUTE JAMES
A bill seeking to make it mandatory for the Executive arm of Government to present national budget in September each year to allow deliberation on it by the lawmakers for at least two months before its passage has passed Second Reading in the House of Representatives.

The bill was sponsored by Rt. Hon. Abbas Tajudeen PhD and co-sponsored by Hon. Mohammed Omar Bio, representative of Banten/Kaima Federal Constituency of Kwara State.
Leading the debate on the bill titled A BILL FOR AN ACT TO REGULATE THE PLANNING, PREPARATION, PASSAGE AND EXECUTION OF THE BUDGET OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT OF NIGERIA AND FOR RELATED MATTERS (HB 23), Hon. Mohammed Bio argued that in Nigeria, the budget process is confronted with a number of issues from bloated or overpriced budget, to irregular budget circle coupled with annual late presentation of budget estimate to the National Assembly.
He said the preparation of the budget, the content, implementation, issues relating to borrowing and what for are other issues not properly addressed in the existing laws. Some of these issues according to him arise from the gap in the constitution.
He said for ease of reference. the relevant section 81 (1) ot the constitution provides as follows: the President shall cause to be prepared and laid before each House of the National Assembly at any time in each financial year estimates of the revenues and expenditure of the Federation for the next following financial year.
“Two issues arise therefrom. First, the constitution seems to permit the President to present the budget estimate to the National Assembly at any time in each financial year. Second is the fact that financial year’ is not defined in the constitution. This leaves the timing of the presentation, passage and signing of the budget to the discretion of both the Executive and the Legislature as was witnessed in the 8” assembly, leading to late investment decisions and haphazard implementation of budget to the extent that at some point in time, two budgets ran and operated at the same time with little or no impact on the citizens.
“It is important to note that this bill does not intend to confront the Constitution in any manner. Rather it is to fill the gaps therein or complement the constitution. The superiority of the constitution remains unwavering,” he said.
According to him, In the 8″ National Assembly, the 2016 budget was signed in May of 2016. The 2017 and 2018 budgets were signed in June of the respective current years and the 2019 budget was signed in May.
He said whilst the financial year retumed to January to December in the 9″ assembly, it still does not have a legal backing.
Read the Lead Debate below:
A budget in any organization is a policy document for development andtransformation. While there could be different meanings or definitions of the word budget’, the Annual National Budget which is of concern and relevance to us as a parliament and as a people is a policy documents that highlights the estimate of expected revenues and expenditure for a period of 12 month usually referred to as fiscal year.
The budget has numerous benefits especially to developing countries of the world like Nigeria as they yawn for progress and advancement. The government uses the budget to influence income distribution, provides essential services for its citizens and transform the country through well-thought out investments and resource allocations thereby helping the government in the implementation of its national development plans, hence the budget is often regarded as the economic blueprint of a country in a fiscal year.
However, for a budget to achieve its purpose, special attention must be paid to the budget process from the moment the budget is birthed, prepared, presented to the Federal Executive Council and to the National Assembly, the budget consideration and passage at the National
Assembly, assent by the president and up to implementation andmonitoring stage of the budget. Once the budget process is faulty, the budget itself is doomed even before it is passed.
In Nigeria, the budget process is confronted with a number of issues from bloated or overpriced budget, to irregular budget circle coupled with annual late presentation of budget estimate to the National Assembly. The preparation of the budget, the content, implementation, issues relating to borrowing and what for are other issues not properly addressed in the existing laws. Some of these issues arise from the gap in the constitution.
For ease of reference. the relevant section 81 (1) ot the constitution provides as follows: the President shall cause to be prepared and laid before each House of the National Assembly at any time in each financial year estimates of the revenues and expenditure of the Federation for the next following financial year.”
Two issues arise therefrom. First, the constitution seems to permit the President to present the budget estimate to the National Assembly at any time in each financial year. Second is the fact that financial year’ is not defined in the constitution. This leaves the timing of the presentation, passage and signing of the budget to the discretion of both the executive and the Legislature as was witnessed in the 8″ assembly, leading to late investment decisions and haphazard implementation of budget to the extent that at some point in time, two budgets ran and operated at the same time with little or no impact on the citizens.
In the 8″ National Assembly, the 2016 budget was signed in May of 2016. The 2017 and 2018 budgets were signed in June of the respective current years and the 2019 budget was signed in May.
Whilst the financial year retumed to January to December in the 9″ assembly, it still does not have a legal backing.
Therefore before you my Honorable colleagues is the National Budget
Bill which seeks to provide for a timeline for the different stages of the budget process, namely, planning, preparation, passage, execution and
auditing. The bill, if passed will also define the fiscal year and the limit of deficit and specifically spell out the reason for borrowing.
Arising from the existing budget challenges already highlighted above and the current economic challenges confronting us as a people, coupled with the decaying state of infrastructure across the country, we cannot undermine the importance of this Bill.
The Bill has 7 parts and 4 clauses Part consists of clause 1 which is the purpose of the Bill; Part 2 is the budget content and planning consisting of 8 clauses; Part 3 is the budget preparation with 9 clauses; Part 4 is budget implementation also comprises 9 clauses; Part 5 is borrowing and public debt with 6 clauses; Part 6 is budget accounting, Control and Audit with 6 clauses, while Part 7 is miscellaneous provisions with 4 clauses which include the citation of the bill.
It is important to note that this bill does not intend to confront the Constitution in any manner. Rather it is to fill the gaps therein or complement the constitution. The superiority of the constitution remains unwavering.
Dear honorable colleagues, while I appreciate the existence of other related laws like the Fiscal Responsibility Act, Finance (Control and Management) Act and the Financial Regulations, none has been able to comprehensively address the issues relating to budget process in Nigeria.
This Bill will therefore serve the dual purposes of filling the gaps in the existing laws and bringing the important provisions of the existing laws under one legal framework for case of implementation and execution.
Due to the gaps in the existing laws like the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as altered), Fiscal Responsibility Act etc, we have not had a disciplined, organized and well defined Budget process and management. The budget, being the nation’s economic blueprint, its processes and management at all stages must be well defined. Hence Clause 2 (2) of this bill refers to the fiscal (financial) year as a period of twelve month commencing on January 1 and ends on December 31.
Clauses 5 and 6 expressly list the contents of revenue and expenditure respectively. Clause 8 prescribes the manner budget surplus is to be used and deficit financed. The bases of budget preparation is prescribed in clause 9 and clause 13 provides that the president shall submit the budget estimate to the National Assembly not later than the 3rd week of
September and the National Assembly shall pass same not later than the first week of December. Clauses 18 to 26 regulates implementation of the budget while clauses 27 to 32 regulates borrowing and public debt.
In conclusion dear Honourable Colleagues, by way of refreshing our memories, the Constitution (Amendment} Bill seeking to prescribe time for the presentation of budget estimates to the National Assembly was vetoed by the president in the 8 assembly. Even though the country has been able to maintain the January to December financial year from the 9″ Assembly, it still lack the enabling legal framework.
Furthermore, aside the issues surrounding the financial year and time for presentation of the budget, the whole budget processand from preparation, planning, contents, implementation evaluation need to be regulated by law. I therefore urge you dear honourable colleagues to support the passage of this Bill.
