Controversies Trail Press Council Amendment Bill as NPO, NPAN, NUJ, NGE, Media Experts Kick, Want its Withdrawal

BY OBUTE JAMES

A Bill for an Act to amend the Nigerian Press Council Act came up for Public Hearing in the House of Representatives penultimate Thursday.

National Assembly Complex

There are indications that the amendments being sought may not see the light of day if the legislstors decide to go by the position of the media organizations, individuals and other stakeholders who spoke and submitted their memoranda on the controversial bill.

Most of the media experts who spoke during the Public Hearing on the bill on Thursday 17th June, 2021 sopke against several clauses of the bill while some requested that the bill be stepped down for going against the Nigerian Constitution and International Laws regarding press freedom.

Two attempts by the lawmakers to amend the Nigerian Press Council Act in the previous National Assembly failed as court ruled against the bill due to inclusion of certain clauses that are inimical to press freedom. The matter is still pending at the Supreme Court of Nigeria.

Presenting a memorandum on the bill last Thursday, the Nigerian Press Organisation, which comprises the Newspaper Proprietors’ Association of Nigeria, Nigerian Guild of Editors and the Nigerian Union of Journalists, called on the House of Representatives to step down the bill seeking to amend the Nigerian Press Council Act, noting that it is still a subject of litigation at the Supreme Court.

Hon. Sani Soro, a former Member of the House of Representatives and Ex-President of Nigerian Union of Journalists, NUJ also said inclusion of certain clauses in the bill like withdrawal of licences of newspapers is a misnomer since most of them are business oriented and registered with Cooperate Affairs Commission.

He said making Nigeria Media as a department of Ministry of Information is unacceptable and also at variance with international laws and Nigerian Constitution.

According to him, Nigeria should throw off defamatory statute in the bill as done by South Africa, Ghana and Sierra Leone.

Another media expert, Lanre Arogundade urged the lawmakers and government functionaries to be careful of the kind of laws they make when they are in government as such laws may hunt them when they are no longer in power.

The House Committee on Information, Nationsl Orientation, Ethics and Values chaired by Hon. Odebunmi Olusegun Doku had between Wednesday 16th and Thursday 17th June, 2021 organized Public Hearing on 5 bills including the Nigerian Press Council Bill.

The long tilte of Nigerian Press Council Bill is “Bill for an Act to Amend the Nigerian Press Council Act, CAP N128, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria, 2004, to Remove Bottlenecks Affecting Its Performance and Make the Council in Tune with Current Realities in Regulating the Press and for Related Matters (HB 330).’

A Bill for an Act to Amend the National Broadcasting Act; A Bill for an Act to Repeal the Advertising Practitioners (Registration etc) Act; A Bill for an Act to Establish the Nigerian Institute of Translating and Interpreting and for Related Matters and A Bill for an Act to Repeal the National Film and Vedeo Censor Board Act all came up for Public Hearing last Thursday.

The Editor-in-Chief of Leadership Newspapers, Azubuike Ishiekwene, who represented the NPO, stated that contrary to the claim of an “open invitation” by the committee, the organisation did not receive any notification that would have enabled it to engage the lawmakers and Nigerians robustly on the bill.

Ishiekwene said, “There is a matter and I am sure that as stewards of the people and the law, you are aware that there is a pending matter between the NPO and some parties involved in this legislation. That is why a negotiated conversation seems to us to be a way to deal with it because there is a matter pending before the Supreme Court: between the NPAN and some parties involved in this bill that is being amended. And as stewards of the law, I am sure you are constrained just as I am to make any further conversations on this matter because it is a pending matter before the Supreme Court.

“The last time it came up in 2010 – it is a matter that has actually been pending since 1999 – 17 of the 39 clauses contained in the bill that you are considering were ruled unconstitutional by the court at that time. Of course, the Federal Government appealed the ruling. We won the appeal and the matter is currently before the Supreme Court.

“I will rest my case by appealing to the honourable members of this committee; I crave your indulgence to refer to a conversation that was had on a similar matter in 2018 when this matter came up before the Senate and the pendency of this matter before the court was canvassed. And the Senate – the 8th National Assembly – at that time agreed that the prudent thing to do was to step it down. I urge this House to also consider a similar step.”

Similarly, the International Press Centre, Media Rights Agenda, Centre for Media Law and Advocacy and the Premium Times Centre for Investigative Journalism, a joint memorandum titled ‘For a Truly Independent and Media Freedom Friendly Nigeria Press Council’, called on the National Assembly to expunge all laws intended to criminalise free speech and press.
The memo was signed by the Executive Director, IPC, Lanre Arogundade; Executive Director, MRA, Edetaen Ojo; Executive Director, CMLA, Richard Akinnola; and Executive Director, PTCIJ, Dapo Olorunyomi.

Arogundade, who read from the memo, said, “First, we like to say that the international behaviour towards media regulation is peer regulation, constitutionally guaranteed freedom of the press, and the expunging from statute all laws that criminalises freedom of expression. This is the line the Committee should tow like Ghana has done and like South Africa has done; and with regards to throwing off defamation statute from the books, the way Sierra Leone has done.

“A consideration is that the amendment seeks an unabashed focus to restrict freedom of expression while masking the toga of something else. It attempts to do what other laws have done like the Cybercrimes Acts which Sections 24 and 38, which in no fewer than ten instances have been used to clampdown on bloggers or journalists for expressing opinion antagonistic to politically or economically powerful elites.

“Bodies like the Amnesty International has documented 50 cases where the law had targeted, not cybercrime suspects, but bloggers and journalists for writing on what they ‘know to be false, for the purpose of causing annoyance, inconvenience danger, obstruction, insult, injury, criminal intimidation, enmity, hatred, ill will or endless anxiety to another.”

Others are that, “The ethical code that should be operationalised by the council is the Code of Ethics of Journalists in Nigeria as adopted by the Nigerian Press Organisation, comprising the Nigeria Union of Journalists, the Nigerian Guild of Editors and the Newspapers Proprietors Association of Nigeria in Ilorin in 1998 and as may be regularly updated. This has been the practice. A political and non-journalism office like that of the Minister of Information should not be given the power of approval over the code of conduct of journalists.

“The power to determine sanctions relating to hefty fines should be vested in the courts and not the council. The Court of Appeal has clearly established this legal principle in NOSDRA v Mobil Producing Nigeria Unlimited (2018) LPELR-44210 (CA) where it held that ‘the imposition of fines by NOSDRA was contrary to its powers on the basis that penalties or fines are imposed as punishment for an offence or violation of the law and the power as well as competence to establish that an offence has been committed belongs to the courts and not a regulatory agency.’

“The provision relating to revocation of license for alleged publication of fake news should be removed from the Act. Decisions for appropriate sanctions in relation to such offences should be vested in the law courts.”

Though Odebunmi, argued that the House was doing its constitutional job as the lawmakers have the mandate to amend laws, there are indications that if the House of Representatives pass the bill, it may not still see the light of the day like the previous two attempts due certain clauses which court had already admitted are inimical to freedom of the press.